August 2001
-- The idea for
this valuable tech article came via Off-Road.Com ex-staffer, Andi Vogt. We've
dug this one up from the ORC archives of many years ago to reintroduce it into
some era other than the dinasaur age. Anyhow, Andi received
the following email and passed it on Rick's way:
The Spark "My brother bought a
new anti-fog helmet this winter. While out riding, though, it fogs up to the
point that he can not see. What are the standards that must be met to sell
merchandise as anti-fogging? Any ideas where I might be able to research this
further? I saw one of your articles said to look for a helmet that is rated by
ANSI or SNELL. Can I find that somewhere on the Web? Or a similar source for
ratings of "ANTI-FOG"?? Any help would be appreciated, or just point
me in the right direction. THANKS!
Paula P.S. The store that sold
the helmet ($100) is not being helpful.
First off, there is no
such thing as an anti-fog helmet. There are, however, anti-fog face shields that
are attached to helmets. While there are, indeed,
standards for helmets, there are NO STANDARDS for anti-fogging shields or
goggles. Since I not only ride and
race (both dirt bikes and off-road trucks), this is a problem that I've had to
deal with over the years. Compounding the problem is the fact that I wear
glasses. This means that I not only have to deal with goggles fogging up, I also
have to deal with the two layers (inner and outer) of the glasses fogging up, as
well. In the process of riding
half-blind at times, I've found out what works and what doesn't work. So
let's share some of this with you. Why
Things Fog Up All face shields or
goggles are made out of some kind of plastic, or glass. They are invariably made
out of transparent stuff. Early attempts with plywood goggles were dismal
failures. All fogging of goggles and
face shields is caused by a difference in temperature and humidity.. If you just
took a pair goggles and put it on a crash test dummy, the goggles would not fog
up, no matter what the outside temperature was. However, when those same
goggles are attached to a human being, that's when the problems start. Let's
say the outside temperature is 60 degrees. The normal temperature of a live
person is 98.6 degrees, which gives you a huge near-40 degree differential. So, you have the ideal
conditions to create a mist of moisture, or fog . But what happens when the
outside temperature and your body temperature are about the same? We've all
had goggles fog up on a 100 degree day, very close to normal body temperature.
So why do goggles fog up then? Simple. Because an area of
the face is covered up with goggles, it raises the skin temperature up
considerably, causing sweat to form on the skin, which then evaporates into the
air, which in turn gets transferred to in the inside of the goggle lens. Instant
fog. An easy demonstration of
how moist air turns into fog can be accomplished by breathing heavily on a glass
surface, such as a mirror. Or just take a real hot
shower in a bathroom on a cool morning, and notice how quickly the mirrors fog
up. Take that same shower on a hot day with the windows open, and very little
fog will be seen on the mirrors. Moving
Air Here's a simple test on
the effect of air on fogged surfaces. Take a hand mirror and breathe heavily on
the glass until it fogs up. Let it sit for a while, and in a few minutes, the
fog will go away. Now, fog up the mirror
again, then wave the mirror around like crazy. In seconds, the fog will
disappear. This is why face shields
and goggles usually don't fog up while your bike (or truck, or buggy, or ATV)
is moving. Trade-offs OK, we know that moving
air will reduce, or eliminate, goggle fogging. This means that some air must be
allowed to get between the covered portion of your face and the inner surface of
the goggles. The more air you let flow
in, the less fogging potential. However, the trade-off is
allowing dust to get into your eyes. If the goggles seal tightly, fogging is a
problem. If you have some air vent gaps, you can get all kinds of grit and dust
in your eyes. Whenever I used to race a
muddy event like the Blackwater 100, I used to tear all the foam out of the
frame of the goggles I was wearing for maximum air flow. This gave me reasonable
eye-protection and completely eliminated goggle fogging. One Blackwater 100 race,
however, had a combination of swampy terrain and some dusty fire roads, and my
eyeballs got sanded-out badly in the dry stuff. Bad move on my part. The next year, I made sure
that the goggles I used had thin foam on the frame, and I sprayed the foam with
Endust to catch the airborne grit. This worked well, but since I crashed my
brains out in a bottomless bog, it was after all, a clever exercise in futility. So, with this in mind, if
you do not coat your goggles (or face shield) with some sort of anti-fog
solution, maximum air flow is a must!
Home
Grown Fog Eliminators In the early days of
off-road racing, we didn't have much in the way of anti-fog chemicals and
solutions, so we made do with what was at hand. And here's what worked way
back then: 1. Soap. Before a race, I used to
take an ordinary bar of hand soap and soak in for a few minutes in water to
soften it up. Then I would scrape some of the softened soap off and make a thin
paste of it with more water. This would then be applied to the inner surface of
the goggles, and allowed to dry for a few minutes. When dry, I would buff the
lens with toilet paper repeatedly until the lens were clear. This worked great
and would give you several hours of decent anti-fogging protection. 2. Liquid Soap. It worked as well as
regular soap, but since I usually forgot to bring any liquid soap with me, I
usually resorted to regular old bar soap. 3. Potato. Yep, you can take a
regular potato and anti-fog your goggles with it. Simply cut a wedge of the
potato and rub the white part on the lens. Let the solution air dry, then buff
it clean, just like the soap trick. 4. Apple. You can use an apple (or
pear) to do the same trick, but it's not as effective. 5.Car Wax. While some riders used car
wax to coat the inner lens as an anti-fogger, I felt that it took way too much
work to buff the wax out enough to remove the hazed glare it left on the lens. 6. Spit. Skin divers have been
doing this for years, but the effect is relatively short.
STUFF YOU CAN BUYThere are a number of
commercial things you can buy to stop fogging, that have nothing to do with
racing. Among them are: Bathroom Cleaners. There are many bathroom
cleaners that work well as anti-fogging agents, but many of them have harsh
chemicals in them that can cause your eyes to burn. Windex. This does a decent job,
and some riders swear by it, but I recommend that you do not use the ammoniated
type. Dow, Ajax and several
other companies make a mirror cleaner/defogger that works well, but again the
evaporating vapors can hurt your eyes, and I've found that their effectiveness
is limited to about 45 minutes or so. Plastic Cleaners. You can find a huge
selection of glass and plastic cleaners at most auto parts stores (Chief, Pep
Boys, etc.) that work reasonably well as anti-fogging agents. They have the
added benefit - in some cases - of reducing scratches and extending lens life. Furniture Polish. Pledge and many other
brands of spray polish can be used to reduce fogging. Some leave a hazy coating
on the lens, and some don't. Experiment to see what works for you.
Specialty
Stuff Various goggle makers sell
anti-fogging solutions and cloths to work with their product, and some of them
toss in that product when you buy the goggles. Some of the best are Smith, Scott
and Bell anti-fog. For my own goggles, I've
come to rely on the Smith No-Fog Cloth. Here's how I use it: 1. Make sure the
lens is clean and dust free. 2. Breathe lightly
on the lens, or moisten the lens with a piece of damp toilet tissue. 3. Wipe the lens
surface with the No-Fog Cloth until it's dry. 4. Breathe heavily
on the lens again. 5. Repeat the cloth
rubbing. 6. Buff any
remaining haze off the lens with a soft towel, or toilet tissue. Under normal conditions, I
find that this will give you about a half-day of fog-free riding.
Options For really cold days of
riding, I don't rely just on the No-Fog Cloth. If you get to one of those
situations where you have to push your bike over an obstacle, or pick it up
after a crash, you might experience some fogging, no matter what you use. For those days, I use a
Smith double Lexan lens. This operates on the same principal as double-glass
windows. These lenses not only have two layers of Lexan, but also have vent
holes in the top edge with foam covering the holes to keep dust out. The outer lens takes the
cold hit of air and the inner lens is much closer to your face temperature. With
these lenses AND an anti-fogging solution, you've got the best possible
combination. For hot weather riding, I
use Smith Turbo goggles. These little beauties have a small fan built into the
frame of the goggles, that you can turn on or off. While you're moving, you
can turn them off, as the normal air flow prevents fogging. When you're going slow,
or stopped for some reason, or horsing your bike over a fallen log, flick the
fan on and the cooling air prevents fogging and perspiration from forming on
your covered face area. My Turbos are older
one-speed models, but Smith now makes a two-speed version, with a low and high
switch. You can get about 50 hours of actual use with the switch in the
low-speed position, and maybe 10 to 15 hours out the faster mode. All this from
a tiny nine-volt battery. The only drawback is that
you can feel the slight extra weight of the fan and the battery on the bridge of
your nose, but it's certainly not objectionable. You're just aware of it. For the absolute ultimate
in anti-fogging, consider using a Turbo goggle with the double-layer vented
Lexan lens, and anti-fogging solution on the lens. If you're wearing a
basic goggle and use anti-fogging solutions, consider some of these helpful
tips: Wear one of those
sweat-absorbing head bands to prevent perspiration from increasing the fogging
possibilities. If you're wearing
glasses, put a small absorbent pad on the bridge of your nose. This is where
perspiration is heavy, and the heat from your face can actually cause beads of
water to form on the inner surface of your glasses. I use small pieces of Dr.
Scholls foot pads cut to fit over the sizeable bridge of my nose. This has a
secondary benefit of keeping you from cutting into the bridge of your nose with
your glasses if you should take one of those ass-over-heels crashes and dig your
helmet into the ground. Trust me on this one, as I crash a lot, and with great
enthusiasm. If you're using a full
coverage helmet with a face shield that fogs up, glue some foam strips to the
lower and side edges of the shield, where it sits against the helmet opening.
This will allow some decent air flow and stop all fogging as long as you're
moving. In warm weather, use a
vented helmet to prevent heat build-up in the helmet itself, which leads to
perspiration on your face, which in turn, contributes to fogging. There are some lenses and
face shields that claim to have been pre-treated with an anti-fog solution. In
my opinion, none of them live up to their claims ? at least the ones I've
tried so far. Flip-up shields. For those
who ride street and use full-face helmets with face shields, get a hinged shield
that can be flipped-up easily. This way, when you experience fogging, say at a
stop light, you can just flick the shield up, and get some air on the inner
surface. Breathe down. If you're
using a full face shield and exhaling through your mouth, extend your upper lip
out a bit and breathe down, rather than straight out at the shield. Hey, this
really helps! In really cold weather,
wear a bandana over your mouth. This keeps you from breathing your hot air
directly onto the face shield and dramatically reduces fogging.
What Doen't Work Don't use Rain-X as an
anti-fogger. While this stuff works great on the outer surface of your goggles
to help with rain and splattering mud, it doesn't help on the inner lens. Anything with ammonia or
harsh chemicals in the solution is a no-no. Even if you let it air dry, moisture
from your face can re-activate the chemical and cause it to irritate or cause a
burning sensation in your eyes. Don't use any soaps with
grit in them, like Lava, as applying the soap will scratch the lens. Don't rub the lens too
much when applying the anti-fog solution, as excess rubbing can cause static
electricity to build up on the lens, which will attract dust and cause it to
stick to the inner lens.
|